About Maple City Insurance Associates

Welcome to Lake Wallenpaupack, The Poconos & Beyond

Paupack Insurance Agency is a division of Maple City Insurance Associates, Inc., t/a Varcoe Insurance and is located at 2555 Route 6, Hawley, Pa.

The agency was founded by Thomas McColligan in the late 1980's and complimented his busy real estate office in the Pocono lake region area. The agency then transferred to Ann Cosgrove in 2003 and steadily grew into a vital servicing location for full time and seasonal residents around the shores of Lake Wallenpaupack . The agency was recently purchased by David & Andrea Murray and compliments their long established location servicing Waymart and surrounding communities in Wayne County.

Varcoe Insurance Agency, established in 1930, is located at 227 Belmont Street in Waymart, PA, and is one of the oldest insurance agencies still in operation in Wayne County.

Our staff includes 5 exceptional insurance professionals. View our staff directory and bios

Together, we service the Lake Wallenpaupack and surrounding area including the counties of Pike, Wayne, Lackawanna, Susquehanna and Monroe throughout Northeastern Pennsylvania.

Both locations are full service, independent agencies offering personalized, professional and friendly service. We're open Monday - Friday (including most Saturdays at the Paupack location) and are conveniently located with plenty of parking available.

As independent insurance agents, we represent a select group of nationally recognized companies, including but not limited to: Progressive, Safeco, Ohio Casualty, Maine Mutual Group, Foremost, Windsor Mount Joy Mutual, Briar Creek Mutual, National Flood Processing Center, Infinity, Dairyland, Aegis and Hagerty Insurance. In addition, we have a network of agents and companies available to assist in placement for some of the more difficult risks that we encounter.

We're members of the Independent Insurance Agents Association, Professional Insurance Agents Association, Wayne County Chamber of Commerce, Pocono Lake Region Chamber of Commerce and Pike/Wayne Association of Realtors.

Free Quotes are available by calling 570-226-8494, in person or online! From Cabins to Castles and Scooters to Custom Rides, we can quote a price for all your Personal and Commercial insurance needs.